Your companion for restful nights

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Review
Founded in 1995, Brooklyn Bedding is a well-established mattress manufacturer. It started out as a retail shop that mostly sold brand name mattresses at closeout prices. In 2009, it launched a website and began to sell mattress-in-a-box products. The newest Brooklyn Bedding mattress, #BestMattressEver, was created in 2015 to simplify the brand’s many options while still meeting various sleep needs. Use this Brooklyn Bedding mattress review to learn how it stacks up to other mattresses.

Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Review Summary

Compressed in a box, the #BestMattressEver mattress from Brooklyn Bedding is constructed of foam and latex mattress layers. It gets high marks for offering three firmness options that each balance bounce, contour and cooling for a great night of sleep.

Brooklyn Bedding owns its own factories, which allows it to sell the #BestMattressEver for low prices compared to luxury brands and even other bed-in-a-box products. The latex layers are certainly unique for this market and are made with high-quality materials.

The only things in our mattress review that could be better are the motion transfer and edge support. The branding on the mattress itself may also be a little too bold for some people.
Check Price

  • It’s affordable.
  • The mattress has a soft, pillow-top layer.
  • It’s designed for box springs, slats and platforms.
  • Three firmness options are available in numerous sizes.
  • The mattress is easy to order and install.
  • Delivery is fast.
  • There’s minimal off-gassing out of the box.
  • Brooklyn Bedding has a great return policy.
  • There’s some motion transfer.
  • It doesn’t offer as much edge support as some similar brands.
  • The in-your-face branding really grabs your attention.
  • Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Overview

With great customer service and high-quality materials, Brooklyn Bedding did really well with its #BestMattressEver. During testing for this mattress review, it was cool to sleep on, provided enough support and was just plain comfortable. However, the motion transfer and edge support could have been better.


For this Brooklyn Bedding mattress review, the price was the biggest benefit. It’s well under what most companies charge for a mattress. It’s even cheaper than other bed-in-a-box brands. Another great aspect is that the mattress can be set up on platforms, slats or box springs.

With three firmness levels, it’s easy to choose the right one and buy online. Brooklyn Bedding delivers quickly via FedEx, and the mattress is easy to install when it arrives. There’s also no need to worry about not liking the mattress because the company has a great return policy with no shipping fees.

Motion Transfer and Sinkage

As with all mattresses, the amount of motion transfer and sinkage that sleepers experience depends on their weight. For two people of average weight, the medium firmness level did well on both accounts. However, we felt like some other mattresses prevent motion transfer better.

The mattress evenly distributes body weight while lying on the back, and the bed only sinks in about 1 inch. While sitting on the edge, however, it sinks about 4 inches. This won’t provide a lot of support for people who gravitate toward the edge of the bed in their sleep.


Before buying the #BestMattressEver, we did some research about its construction for this mattress review. Here’s a quick overview of the three layers from foundation to top.

High-Density Poly Foam – This is the 6-inch foundation of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress. The 2-pound polyurethane foam core is built to last and combat sagging.
Dunlop Latex – This 2-inch layer is a transitional layer that supports both the foundation and top layer.
Talay Latex – This 2-inch layer is what provides comfort and supportive contour during sleep. It responds to the body and stays cool during the night.

The quilted cover is a blend of cotton and polyester. It features a ¾-inch thick polyfoam that’s plush and soft. It also sleeps cool so that a cooling pad isn’t necessary. The cover also has a simple design that’s pleasing to the eye.

Firmness and Comfort

On a scale of one to 10, the medium firmness ranks at about 6. This is ideal for back, side and stomach sleeping. This is the firmness that we chose to test for this Brooklyn Bedding mattress review. It provided the perfect amount of support and was very comfortable.

However, Brooklyn Bedding offers soft and firm levels as well. The soft level is ideal for people who mostly sleep on their sides and want to sink into their mattress. The firm level is ideal for those who sleep on their backs or stomachs and don’t want to sink into the mattress.


It’s evident from the prices below that Brooklyn Bedding is affordable. Although it’s not the cheapest bed in a box, it’s one of the best quality options for the price.

Twin – $450
Twin XL – $475
Full – $650
Full XL – $700
Queen – $750
Queen (short) – $750
King – $900
California King – $900
Split California King – $1,050

The disadvantages are few for the #BestMattressEver. The biggest is that there’s still some motion transfer despite the latex foam layers. Better edge support would also be welcome for people who toss and turn toward the edge of the bed during the night.

The branding around the edges of the bed might be a little tacky and unappealing to some people. The company logo is spaced only a couple of inches apart around the whole mattress.

Service for Brooklyn Bedding Mattress

One aspect that makes Brooklyn Bedding so great is its customer service. It takes pride in offering some of the best in the business. With that comes a great warranty, trial period and free shipping.

Guarantee and Trial Period

Each Brooklyn Bedding mattress comes with a 10-year warranty. This starts from the date of purchase. If a defect occurs during this period, Brooklyn Bedding will replace or repair the mattress.

You can also try the #BestMattressEver for 120 nights at no risk. This is much longer than average in the mattress industry. We didn’t experience the exchange or return process for this mattress review, but Brooklyn Bedding is known for offering a seamless process. There’s no shipping cost for returning a mattress.


Shipping to the 48 contiguous states is free via FedEx for all mattresses. It took just six days for ours to arrive. However, FedEx two-day shipping is available for $75.

There’s a $250 fee for shipping to Alaska and Hawaii. Brooklyn Bedding estimates that deliveries arrive within three to four business days after two to three days of processing.
Check Price